Every January, shops fill with people holding jumpers in the wrong size, shoes that pinch and presents nobody asked for. Many assume the law lets them hand those gifts back. Usually it does not. In the US, the UK and the EU, a shop that sold a perfectly good item over the counter can refuse to take it back, and a gift receipt is a favour, not a legal right. The picture changes when the gift was bought online, when it is faulty, or when a US store fails to post its policy. Here is what the law says and who holds the rights to a present.
Short answer: In the US, UK and EU there is usually no legal right to return a non-faulty gift bought in a shop; returns and gift receipts are store policy. Online purchases are different: UK and EU law gives the buyer 14 days from delivery to cancel. Faulty items carry legal rights everywhere, and those rights belong to the person who paid.
Key takeaways
- Changing your mind about something bought in a shop gives no legal right to a refund in the UK or EU, and US law leaves it to store policy, subject to state posting rules.
- Online purchases from a business carry a 14-day cancellation right in the UK and EU, counted from the day the goods reach the buyer or the person the buyer named.
- Faulty goods are different: the UK gives 30 days to reject for a full refund, and EU law makes the seller liable for faults appearing within at least two years.
- The legal rights sit with the buyer, not the recipient, so a gift receipt or the buyer’s help is often what makes a return possible.
Can you return a gift without a receipt?
For an item that is not faulty, only if the shop’s policy allows it, and many policies require a receipt, gift receipt or order number. The US Federal Trade Commission’s holiday advice warns that returning or exchanging in store “often requires documentation, and maybe an ID”, and that without a receipt shoppers should expect store credit, often at the lowest sale price.
If you want to return gifts without a receipt, ask the giver for an order confirmation email or card statement, or accept an exchange or credit. Faulty goods are easier: UK and EU law asks whether the goods were faulty, not whether you kept the till slip, so any reliable proof that the item came from that seller should do.
FLJ Insider Pro is open: live fashion law jobs and internships, five career guides and two roadmaps. Early bird USD 12/month. See what's inside
Do shops have to take back unwanted clothes bought in store?
In the UK, no. Citizens Advice says you have no automatic right to your money back if you change your mind about something you bought and there is nothing wrong with it, however expensive it was, and that this is so even if you could not try it on because the changing rooms were closed. The 14 or 30 days many shops offer is goodwill.
EU law is the same. The 14-day right of withdrawal in the Consumer Rights Directive covers only distance contracts (online, phone, mail order) and off-premises contracts. A dress bought at a till in Paris or Madrid can be returned for a change of mind only if the shop’s policy, or national law, allows it.
The US has no federal right to return non-faulty goods, but some states regulate how stores disclose their policy:
- California. Civil Code section 1723 requires a retailer that will not give a full refund, credit or equal exchange for at least seven days after purchase to display its policy clearly. According to the California Attorney General, if it does not, you can return the item with proof of purchase for a full refund within 30 days. Food, plants, final-sale and “as is” items, used or damaged goods, custom orders, goods not in original packaging and goods that cannot be resold for health reasons are excluded.
- New York. General Business Law section 218-a requires retailers, including online retailers, to post their refund policy conspicuously. A retailer that breaks the section must accept returns for up to 30 days, with a cash refund or credit at the buyer’s choice, if the item is unused and undamaged and the purchase date can be verified.
The FTC’s Cooling-Off Rule (16 CFR Part 429) is narrow: it covers door-to-door style sales, such as those at your home for $25 or more or at temporary venues like hotel rooms for $130 or more, and it excludes arts and crafts sold at fairs, so it will not help with a present from a Christmas market.
What changes when the gift was bought online?
A lot, in the UK and EU. Under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 and Article 9 of the EU Consumer Rights Directive, a consumer who buys goods from a business at a distance can cancel within 14 days without giving a reason.
- When the clock starts. The 14 days run from when the goods reach the consumer or a person, other than the courier, whom the consumer named. A gift sent straight to the recipient on 3 December may be out of time by Christmas Day.
- Sending it back. After telling the seller, the buyer has another 14 days to send the goods. The buyer pays return postage only if the seller said so before the sale.
- The refund. Under regulation 34, the seller must refund the price and standard delivery within 14 days of getting the goods back or proof of posting, whichever is first, to the original payment method.
- Missing information. If the seller never explained the right to cancel, the period is extended by up to 12 months.
The EU added a new tool this year. Directive (EU) 2023/2673, which member states had to apply from 19 June 2026, requires online sellers to offer a withdrawal function labelled “withdraw from contract here” or similar, available throughout the 14 days, followed by a “confirm withdrawal” step. FLJ’s guide to online returns law for fashion brands covers these rules from the seller’s side. In the US, online purchases carry no general right to cancel; the retailer’s policy governs.

What are your rights if the gift is faulty?
In the UK, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires goods to be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose and as described. If they are not:
- the buyer can reject them for a full refund within 30 days under section 22;
- outside that window, or instead, the buyer can ask for a repair or replacement, and if one attempt fails, a price reduction or final right to reject;
- a fault appearing within six months of delivery is presumed to have been there from the start (section 19(14)); and
- in England and Wales, a contract claim can be brought for up to six years.
These rights do not cover wear and tear, accidents or faults you were told about before buying.
In the EU, Directive (EU) 2019/771 makes the seller liable for faults that existed at delivery and appear within two years, and countries may set longer periods. Faults appearing within one year (two in some countries) are presumed to have existed at delivery. Repair or replacement comes first; a price cut or termination follows if that fails. The Right to Repair Directive, (EU) 2024/1799, applicable from 31 July 2026, extends the seller’s liability once by 12 months where the consumer chooses repair.
In the US, the FTC explains that every state’s law creates implied warranties, including a promise that a product will do what it is meant to do. Sellers can disclaim them by selling “as is” where state law allows, and in some states they last up to four years.
Who holds the rights to a gift: the buyer or the recipient?
The buyer. Consumer rights come from the contract of sale, and the recipient was not a party to it. That is why online cancellation must come from the person who ordered, and why refunds go back to the original card.
A gift receipt is the retailer’s goodwill promise to the recipient, usually an exchange or credit rather than cash. In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 lets a non-party enforce a term that expressly gives them a right, or that purports to benefit them and identifies them by name, class or description. Whether a gift receipt meets that test depends on its wording, so for a faulty present the easiest route is often for the giver to make the claim.
Can you return worn clothes, swimwear, earrings or sale items?
Worn clothes. In a shop, a no-wear rule is store policy. Online, the Consumer Rights Directive’s recitals say a buyer may try clothes on but not wear them. Under UK regulation 34(9) and (12), the seller may deduct any loss in value caused by handling beyond what a shop would allow. You keep the right to cancel; the seller recovers the drop in value.
Hygiene items. The cancellation right ends for sealed goods unsuitable for return for health or hygiene reasons once unsealed after delivery (UK regulation 28(3)(a); EU Article 16(e)). Citizens Advice gives earrings with a broken hygiene seal as an example. The exception is narrow: in slewo (Case C-681/17, 27 March 2019) the EU Court of Justice held that a mattress with its protective film removed could still be returned, comparing it with clothing a trader can clean and resell. Unsealed swimwear is not automatically excluded online, though removing a hygiene liner may justify a deduction.
Sale items. Shops often limit change-of-mind returns on sale stock, and California’s posting rule excludes final-sale items. Rights for faults still apply, except for defects pointed out before purchase (section 9(4) of the Consumer Rights Act). To judge whether a festive deal was real, see FLJ’s explainer on Black Friday fake discounts.
Are extended Christmas return windows legally binding?
Many retailers extend returns for purchases made from November so gifts can go back in January. No law requires this, but a published policy generally becomes part of the deal and should be honoured on its own terms, including conditions such as “unworn, with tags”. For UK and EU online orders, the goodwill window sits on top of the 14-day statutory period, not in place of it. Check whether it counts from purchase or delivery. If a retailer collapses after Christmas, returns and gift cards can be restricted, as FLJ’s account of the Forever 21 closures shows.
What about gifts bought on marketplaces or from private sellers?
Statutory return rights apply only against traders. Citizens Advice notes there is no cooling-off period when buying from a private individual on a social media marketplace or auction site. In the EU, Article 6a of the Consumer Rights Directive requires marketplaces to tell you before you buy whether the seller is a trader and, if not, that EU consumer rights do not apply. Where the seller is a business, your rights are against it, and the platform may add its own guarantee. If a branded gift turns out to be fake, FLJ’s guide to counterfeits on Amazon and your refund rights sets out the options.
How do the US, UK and EU rules compare?
| Situation | United States | United Kingdom | European Union |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unwanted item bought in store | Store policy; 30-day return in California and New York if the policy is not properly posted | No legal right | No EU right; store policy or national law |
| Unwanted item bought online | Store policy | 14 days from delivery to cancel | 14 days from delivery; online withdrawal function |
| Faulty item | State implied warranties unless validly disclaimed | 30-day right to reject, then repair or replacement | Seller liable for at least two years |
| Opened hygiene-sealed item (online) | Store policy | Cancellation right lost | Withdrawal right lost |
| Private marketplace seller | Platform rules | No cooling-off period | EU consumer rights do not apply |
| Who holds the rights | Buyer | Buyer | Buyer |
Sources: Consumer Rights Act 2015; Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013; Directives 2011/83/EU, (EU) 2019/771, (EU) 2023/2673 and (EU) 2024/1799; California Civil Code section 1723; New York General Business Law section 218-a; FTC.
This article is general information on US, UK and EU consumer law as of 21 November 2026. It is not legal advice. National and state rules vary, and retailers’ policies may give more than the law requires.
Frequently asked questions
Can I return a gift without a receipt?
Only if the shop’s policy allows it, unless the item is faulty. Many stores offer an exchange or store credit, often at the lowest recent price. For a faulty item, an order email or card statement can serve as proof of purchase.
Do UK shops have to accept Christmas returns?
Not for non-faulty items bought in store; extended Christmas returns are goodwill. Online purchases from a business can be cancelled within 14 days of delivery, and faulty goods rejected within 30 days.
Can I return clothes I have worn?
Shops can refuse worn items bought in store. For UK and EU online orders you can still cancel within 14 days, but the seller may deduct the loss in value caused by wearing them.
Who can return a gift, the buyer or the recipient?
Legally, the buyer, because the rights come from the contract of sale. Recipients rely on a gift receipt, the shop’s policy or the buyer acting for them.
Can I return earrings or swimwear?
Online, sealed hygiene items such as earrings lose the cancellation right once unsealed. Unsealed swimwear is not automatically excluded, though removing a liner may lead to a deduction. In store, it is up to the shop.
How long do I have to return a faulty gift?
In the UK, 30 days for a full refund, then repair or replacement, with claims possible for up to six years in England and Wales. In the EU, the seller is liable for faults appearing within at least two years.
FASHION LAW JOURNAL INSIDER
Join designers, brand founders and fashion lawyers who get the biggest brand battles, IP fights and career moves in fashion law, straight to their inbox.



