NewFLJ Insider Pro: live fashion law jobs and internships, 5 career guides and 2 roadmaps. Early bird USD 20USD 12/monthJoin now
A Practical Guide to Fashion Law, Second Edition: every chapter rewritten. Get it on Amazon.A Practical Guide to Fashion Law, Second Edition. Get it on Amazon.

Amazon Merch on Demand Ruling: What Apparel Brands Should Learn From Weekend Warrior’s Fight

George Laiolo, partner at Watstein Terepka LLP
George Laiolo, partner at Watstein Terepka LLP. Photo courtesy of Watstein Terepka LLP.

If you run an apparel brand, you have probably found your own designs on a print-on-demand site at least once. Most small brands file a takedown, watch a new copy appear the following week, and eventually give up. A ruling in Ohio this month suggests that giving up may be leaving money on the table.

On 14 October 2026, Judge Douglas R. Cole of the US District Court for the Southern District of Ohio refused to grant Amazon summary judgment on direct and vicarious copyright infringement claims brought by Weekend Warrior Clothing, a T-shirt company run by two brothers, over designs sold through Amazon’s Merch on Demand. The contributory infringement claim was dismissed, but the case is headed for trial.

Why Amazon could be treated as the seller

The court focused on what Amazon itself does on Merch on Demand. It generates the product images, sets the price, names itself as the seller, prints the shirt, ships it and collects the money, paying the uploader a “royalty.” Judge Cole compared that to a copy shop that keeps your copy, displays it in the window with a “buy these here” sign and sells it to passers-by. That shop, he wrote, “is no longer passively providing a machine.”

For brand owners, the point is simple: the more a platform controls the sale, the harder it is for it to claim it is just hosting someone else’s listing.

FLJ Insider Pro is open: live fashion law jobs and internships, five career guides and two roadmaps. Early bird USD 12/month. See what's inside

The notices mattered most

Weekend Warrior’s co-founder Tim Whelan filed infringement notices. Amazon’s automated system flagged him as fraudulent and sent his later emails to the trash. The court called Amazon’s response “dismal” and said a jury could find willful blindness, which keeps enhanced statutory damages in play. The same failure meant Amazon could not win its DMCA safe harbour defence at this stage.

George Laiolo of Watstein Terepka LLP, one of Weekend Warrior’s lead attorneys, put it this way:

“This problem plagues the entire print-on-demand industry. Companies like Amazon know their shops are filled with knockoffs, but they also know those knockoffs make a lot of money. So they make it extremely difficult for independent brands to police their IP, hoping that they’ll give up and just accept mass counterfeiting as a cost of doing business. The Whelans refused to give up. They look forward to proving their case in what will be the first copyright jury trial Amazon has ever faced.”

Read next on Fashion Law Journal: Counterfeits on Amazon: Your Refund Rights, Copyright Infringement in Fashion: Prints, Photos and Designs and Trade Dress in Fashion: What It Protects That Trademark Doesn’t. You can also see our brand protection masterclass.

What brand owners should do now

  • Register before you need to. Weekend Warrior could not claim statutory damages for 22 designs that were not registered in time. In the US, statutory damages and attorney’s fees are only available if a work is registered before the infringement starts, or within three months of first publication.
  • Keep a record of every notice. Save the date, the listing URL, a screenshot and the platform’s response or silence. In this case, the paper trail of ignored notices did the heavy lifting.
  • Keep your design files. Amazon is challenging whether some designs are original or derivative of reference images. Keep sketches, source files and dated drafts.
  • Look at who sells, not just who uploads. If the platform sets the price and ships the product, it may be a target in its own right.

For the full litigation breakdown, read our sister publication’s report on Weekend Warrior v Amazon on Legal Desire.

This article is general information and not legal advice. The case has not been decided on the merits.

Featured image: George Laiolo, partner at Watstein Terepka LLP. Photo courtesy of Watstein Terepka LLP.

FASHION LAW JOURNAL INSIDER

Join designers, brand founders and fashion lawyers who get the biggest brand battles, IP fights and career moves in fashion law, straight to their inbox.

Anuj Kumar

Anuj Kumar is a lawyer, author of a book on Fashion Law, and founder and Editor-in-Chief of Fashion Law Journal and Legal Desire Media (est. 2012).

Garment workers in blue uniforms and hairnets sewing at industrial machines beside stacks of fabric
Previous Story

Ethical Clothing Brands: How to Check the Claims Before You Buy

Sol de Janeiro's dupe
Next Story

Sol de Janeiro’s Dupe Lawsuit Against MCoBeauty Hits a Legal Roadblock

Don't Miss

trend, vibe, fashion, are microtrends dying, microtrends decline, are microtrends over

Is This the End for Microtrends? A Deep Dive into Fashion’s Ever-Changing Trend Cycle

Fashion. It’s a whirlwind, isn’t it? A constantly spinning carousel…